Can Artificial Reoxygenation Revitalize Dying Coastal Seas?

Caroline Slomp, Andreas Oschlies, Andrew Altieri, Lennart Bach, Laurent Bopp, Denise Breitburg, Anna Canning, Daniel Joseph Conley , Minhan Dai, Boris Dewitte, Henrik Enevoldsen, Erica Ferrer, Alex Galan, Veronique Garcon, Marilaure Gregoire, Bo Gustafsson, Dimitri Gutierrez, Patricia Handmann, Astrid Hylen, Kirsten Isensee, Rudy Lamond, Ming Li, Karen Limburg, Ivonne Montes, Jeremy Sterling, Aileen Tan Shau Hwai, Jeremy Testa, Douglas Wallace, Joanna Waniek, Moriaki Yasuhara

Eutrophication and global warming are key drivers of oxygen loss, also termed deoxygenation, in coastal ecosystems worldwide. Artificial reoxygenation has been put forward as a local or regional solution to increase oxygen concentrations and improve water quality. Three main approaches have been proposed: (1) bubbling with air with the aim to destratify and mix the water column (2) injection of pure oxygen and (3) pumping of oxygenated water to greater water depths (downwelling). In this review, we summarize the results of recent field trials and other implementations of artificial reoxygenation in coastal systems, which, to date, only involve small bays and estuaries. We also discuss potential benefits and risks. While the recent trials indicate that reoxygenation of the water column can be achieved, low oxygen conditions returned rapidly within days to months of discontinuing operations, illustrating that artificial reoxygenation typically only provides a temporary solution. Potential side effects of artificial reoxygenation could include enhanced emissions of the greenhouse gas carbon dioxide and, upon bubbling and destratification in shallow waters, also of methane. Additionally, downwelling could lead to warming and an associated increased oxygen demand near the seafloor. Reoxygenation will not necessarily affect nutrient availability for phytoplankton, implying that water quality may remain poor. We recommend a careful, case-by-case assessment of the suitability of artificial reoxygenation in coastal systems prior to implementation and monitoring before, during and after each intervention. Any field trials should involve all relevant parties, including scientists and local communities, and results should be reported with full transparency. While in the short term artificial reoxygenation may be useful to alleviate oxygen loss, long-term improvements in the oxygen levels and quality of coastal waters require reductions in nutrient inputs and greenhouse gas emissions.