The salmonid and the subsurface: Hillslope storage capacity determines the quality and distribution of fish habitat

David Nicholas Dralle , Gabriel Rossi, Phil Georgakakos, W Jesse Hahm, Daniella M Rempe, Monica Blanchard, Mary Power, William Dietrich, Stephanie Carlson

Water in rivers is delivered via the critical zone that mantles landscapes. Consequently, the success of stream-rearing salmonids depends on the structure and resulting water storage and release processes of this zone. Physical processes below the land surface (the subsurface component of the critical zone) ultimately determine how landscapes ‘filter’ climate to manifest ecologically significant stream flow and temperature regimes. Subsurface water storage capacity of the critical zone has emerged as a key hydrologic variable that integrates many of these subsurface processes, helping to explain flow regimes and terrestrial plant community composition. Here, we investigate how subsurface storage controls flow, temperature and energetic regimes that matter for salmonids. We illustrate the explanatory power of broadly applicable, storage-based frameworks across a lithological gradient that spans the Eel River watershed of California. Study sites are climatically similar but differ in their geologies and consequent subsurface critical zone structure that dictates water storage dynamics, leading to dramatically different hydrographs, temperature, and riparian regimes – with consequences for every aspect of salmonid life history. Lithological controls on the development of key subsurface critical zone properties like storage capacity suggest a heretofore unexplored link between salmonids and geology, adding to a rich literature that highlights various fluvial and geomorphic influences on salmonid diversity and distribution. Rapidly advancing methods for estimating and observing subsurface water storage dynamics at large scales present new opportunities for more clearly identifying landscape features that constrain the distributions and abundances of organisms, including salmonids, at watershed scales.